Admittedly I have a small seafoam collection, but just enough to make my eyes pop.
I won't number these, but from top to bottom they are:
-Wet n Wild I Dream of Greenie browbone (LE)
-Wet n Wild I Dream of Greenie crease (LE)
-Maybelline Icy Mint Colour Tattoo (LE)
-Stila Stay All Day Liquid Waterproof Eyeliner in Turquoise
Out of these, I wear I Dream Of Greenie the most. It's just so wearable (okay, for me, I acknowledge that seafoam doesn't fall in the range of what most people would consider 'wearable'). I don't reach for Icy Mint at all because I forget it exists most of the time. Stila Turquoise is a great pop of subtle colour on the lashline, but it only really works if you're not wearing eyeshadow.
What do you think of seafoam?